Ye Olde Pizza Pub Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Ye Olde Pizza Pub, a beloved Hamilton gem nestled at 2528 NY-12B. Renowned for its delicious pizzas, hearty salads, and rustic taters, this cozy eatery is perfect for gathering with friends and family.

  • Pizzas: Crafted with care, the pizzas are celebrated for their robust flavors and generous toppings.
  • Taters: Simple yet legendary, these comforting bites have earned a loyal fan base.
  • Wings: Always delivering high quality, these wings are a must-try for any visitor.

Though recent reviews indicate a dip in consistency and service, many long-time patrons cherish the camaraderie and warm atmosphere. The homey vibe and local charm make Ye Olde Pizza Pub a spot to reminisce and create new memories, even amidst the culinary ups and downs.

Pizzas
Wings
Sauces
Salads And Subs
Subs
Dinners
Sides
Appetizers
Desserts
Beverages

Pizzas

Pizzas
US$8.75

Additional Toppings

thick crust 1 topping. try our tasty garlic ”white pizza” for a change or spicy sauce at no additional charge. meats: pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami, meatballs, bacon, hamburger, bacon bits, anchovies. veggies: mushrooms, sweet onions, green peppers, black olives, broccoli, tomatoes, red onions, cauliflower, hot peppers, pineapple
US$1.30

Chicken Wing Pizza
US$13.99

Pulled Pork Pizza
US$13.99

10 Wings
US$7.95

15 Wings
US$11.90

20 Wings
US$13.95

25 Wings
US$17.45

30 Wings
US$20.90

35 Wings
US$24.40

40 Wings
US$27.90

45 Wings
US$31.40

50 Wings
US$32.95

100 Wings
US$59.95

Wings

Sauces

Boss

bob’s original sweet and spicy

Bbq

traditional bbq

Kentucky Bourbon

sweet and smokey bbq made with 100 proof wild turkey

Honey Mustard

honey mustard with a mellow hickory smoke taste

Italian Garlic

lite and buttery in taste with parmesan cheese and italian spices

Polynesian

sweet and sour with a touch of heat

Death Sauce

limit 1 wing, you will need to sign a waiver enough said

Salad Bar

yes we still have one of those we feature a nice variety of fresh crisp veggies, salads and sides all of our dressings and salads are homemade from our family recipes
US$2.75

Antipasto

salami-provolone-lettuce-tomatoes-green peppersonions-black olives-hot peppers. italian dressing unless specified
US$5.95

Chicken Ranch

sliced breaded chicken breast on lettucetomatoes-onions-cucumbers with croutons. ranch dressing unless specified
US$6.95

Chef Salad

lettuce-tomatoes-green peppers-onions-cucumbers. ranch dressing unless specified
US$4.95

Salads And Subs

Subs

Vegi

lettuce, tomatoes, onions, american cheese, mayo, salt/pepper
US$4.50

Ham-n-cheese

ham, american cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo
US$4.50

Turkey

turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo
US$4.50

Italian

ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, olives, italian dressing, mayo
US$4.50

Meatball

meatballs, marinara sauce, parmesan, mozzarella cheese
US$4.50

Sausage

ground sausage, tomato sauce, parmesan, mozzarella cheese
US$4.50

Chicken Parmesan

breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, parmesan, provolone cheese
US$4.50

1pc Tickler

with a side of taters
US$2.35

2pc Snack

with a side of taters
US$3.95

3pc Dinner

with a side of taters along with your choice of chili, coleslaw or extra taters
US$5.95

Fish Dinner

with a side of taters along with your choice of chili, coleslaw or extra taters
US$8.95

1pc Fish

tartar sauce and lemmon
US$7.50

Dinners

Sides

Coleslaw
US$1.50

Chili
US$1.95

Bleu Cheese

not just a dressing/dip it’s a way of life
US$0.42

Sauces / Dressings / Dips
US$0.42

Taters
US$1.35

Mozzarella Sticks
US$5.95

Bread Sticks
US$5.95

Fried Dough
US$5.95

Loaded Taters

“hard to believe that you can make a tater taste even better” taters with loaded with monterey jack, cheddar and mozzarella cheese then topped with bacon and a side of our special spicy ranch dip
US$6.95

Haystack Onions

once you try these you’ll hooked we slice an onion nice and thin then let it bath in yuengling lager until drunk then are breaded and fried until lite and crispy served with our own cajun horseradish dip
US$6.95

Pub Tenders

select breast meat batter dipped then breaded and fried to tender perfection. served sauced or plain with your choice of dipping sauce
US$3.25

Appetizers

Desserts

Home Made Milkshakes

chocolate, vanilla, strawberry
US$2.75

Floats

coke, root beer, sprite, strawberry, vanilla
US$2.75

Fried Dough
US$5.95

Novelty Ice-creams
US$1.00

Slush Puppies
US$2.95

Soda

coke, sprite, diet, rootbeer, sweet tea, mnt, berry. we also carry a variety of bottled soda and juices prices vary 1.60 - 2.10
US$1.25

Beer

coors, yuengling, saranac, old milwaukee
US$2.95

Wine
US$3.50

Wine Slushies’

sangria slush, moscato frost
US$4.95

Beverages