Welcome to Ye Olde Pizza Pub
Ye Olde Pizza Pub, nestled in Hamilton, NY, has become a local staple for pizza enthusiasts. This charming establishment offers a cozy atmosphere where friends gather over pizza, salads, and their renowned taters. Customers rave about the homemade dressings and the vibrant camaraderie among patrons. However, recent reviews highlight a decline in food quality and service, with some diners expressing nostalgia for its former glory. Despite mixed opinions, the pub remains a beloved gathering spot, where memorable moments are shared over consistently enjoyable dishes like pizza and wings. It’s worth a visit for the experience alone, even amidst fluctuating quality.
Ye Olde Pizza Pub: Reviews & Ratings
I moved to the area 2 yrs ago and this is an amazing place for pizza, salad, and taters... especially love their homemade dressing
While the food isn't amazing, the memories and camaraderie can't be beat. The taters are simple, but legendary.
I've eaten there for years and have known the family that owns it for years. Great food Great friends and a nice place to hang out.
Amazing Pizza&Wings. I always get the highest and consistent quality orders from the pizza pub! I’ll pop service to 3 stars only because getting charged 40.03 for a medium and 15 wings is highly overpriced. If the app worked and I did not have to call-in the order it would have been around 25-30 so that makes 0 sense.
This place used to be a favorite for many people. In the last 3 or 4 years, it has taken a turn. The food is definitely not as good as it used to be. The whole place is run by teenagers. You'll never see anyone older than 18 or 19 there. We used to LOVE the pizza, taters, and chicken wings. Now, every time we get food from there, we talk about not wanting to get it again. The quality of the food has just decreased. I got a fish fry there today that was so gross. The fish had to have been frozen. Typically, if you get a fish fry at any local pizzerias on a Friday, it's fresh, and they either beer battered it or breaded it themselves. This was 100% not done at the pizza pub. It's very sad to lose this once treasured restaurant. I have been eating there for more than 20 years. But I really don't recommend it anymore.
I was up here for my niece’s wedding at Camp Fiver,they ordered pizzas Thursday evening,2 pepperoni 1 vegetable pizza and 2 cheese pizzas. I’m gonna tell you right now...THAT PIZZA WAS THE BEST I’VE EATEN IN YEARSSSSSS!!!! Thank you for putting your heart and soul and foot into making that pizza. The crust was amazing,now you know if the crust is good,the pizza is good. It reminded me of my youth growing up on the city in Queens NY. I’m telling everyone that decides to come your way or passing by,please stop and this business and get their pizza. It will not disappoint!! Thank you again guys for making pizza the correct way
Great pizza and wings. I have tried most pizzas in the area and this is the best - the crust is the difference - fluffy not chewy. Takeout only during pandemic - unique, rustic bench seating is cozy and fun. Low lighting great for my sensitive eyes
Ye Olde Pizza Pub has remained a family favorite since I was a child. Now I take my kids there. The food is excellent and they play movies on a big screen while you eat. You'll never find a place with the unique taste of the pizza and breaded wings, not to mention their potato wedges. The owner and the employees are super humble, kind, and friendly. They care about their customers' experience. I highly recommend Ye Olde Pizza Pub.
Location
-
2528 NY-12B, Hamilton, NY 13346, United States Hotline: +1 315-824-1800
Welcome to Ye Olde Pizza Pub, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hamilton, New York, at 2528 NY-12B. With its inviting atmosphere and a dedication to crafting comfort food, Ye Olde Pizza Pub has established itself as a local favorite over the years. From their trademark pizzas to hearty salads and legendary taters, this establishment prides itself on providing satisfying dishes that bring people together.
As the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, it's clear that this venue is more than just a place to eat; it is a community hub. The words of local patrons resonate with this sentiment—Lori raves about the “amazing pizza, salad, and taters,” highlighting the homemade dressing that elevates every meal. Brandon Himoff reflects on the camaraderie, saying, “While the food isn't amazing, the memories and togetherness can't be beat,” emphasizing the social aspect of the dining experience.
A glance at the menu reveals a dedication to classic recipes paired with a direct connection to the community. The pizza at Ye Olde Pizza Pub often garners praise for its flavor and consistency, with Bhailis noting the quality of both pizza and wings. However, it’s not without its criticisms. Some patrons, like Sarah Williams, lament a decline in quality over the last few years, an observation echoed by others who fondly recall the pub's prime days.
The place encapsulates the joy of gathering with friends, as Jay Warner reminisces about the years spent enjoying the food and company. Even with mixed reviews, one cannot overlook the impactful role Ye Olde Pizza Pub has played in the community—serving as a backdrop for laughter and shared memories.
While some diners may have reservations about recent experiences, the essence of Ye Olde Pizza Pub remains; it’s a slice of local history steeped in friendships, late-night cravings, and the nostalgic charm of pizza nights gone by. Make a point to visit, roll up your sleeves, and indulge in everything from their classic pizzas to the simply delightful taters. Let this pub remind you: the best meals are often shared with those who mean the most. So grab a slice and a friend, and savor the atmosphere that makes Ye Olde Pizza Pub a beloved spot in Hamilton.